Is the Modern Orthodox Jewish Community Killing Itself? – Part 1

Modern Orthodox Judaism thrives in a few communities today. There are significant communities in large cities: parts of metro New York, Chicago, Los Angeles, Miami, Washington and the like. There are also interesting pockets of modern Orthodoxy in Canada, Mexico and in medium sized communities across North America.

But will the economic crises help to kill off modern Orthodoxy within a generation or two? Here’s what may be emerging:

So-called “right wing” Orthodox institutions — overnight summer camps, day camps, early childhood programs and day schools / yeshivot — tend to charge a lower fee. In many cases, these institutions must do so in recognition of the large families who struggle to pay fees for several children at a time. They are able to do this through a number of means: hiring young and/or lesser qualified staff, large class sizes, offering “no frills” programs, extensive fundraising and more.

What can be easily observed, at least in Long Island (where I live), is that the financial crisis that embraces us all has pushed many modern Orthodox parents to enroll their kids in more affordable, but theologically right-wing programs.

In our particular neighborhood, we are constantly hearing of children whose families lead modern Orthodox lives being enrolled in summer camps and even day schools whose religious practices are far to the “right” of them, but whose fee scale allows them to keep their children in Jewish camps and schools.

I have no particular problem with religious “crossover” within the Jewish community. However the impact on modern Orthodoxy may not be fully realized for another 10 -20 years. Children are certainly influenced (as indeed we would want them to be) by the educators and camp counselors that teach them. And when the staffs are outspoken in their attitudes regarding anything from exposure to American pop culture to the Internet to dress codes, dissonance is being introduced when they return to their modern Orthodox homes.

I have no simple answers, particularly when the economy is what it is. But modern Orthodox leaders (rabbis included) must realize that an educational challenge is emerging that will impact its community down the road. As kids attend some of the more stringently Orthodox camps, rather than the modern Orthodox and/or religious Zionist camps, and study in more stringently Orthodox schools because of affordability, the modern Orthodox world is in danger of not being able to effectively raise the next generation of modern Orthodox leadership.

This is part one of a few postings about the potential dangers that modern Orthodoxy has created for itself. More to follow.

2 responses

  1. Is there no middle ground between modern orthodoxy and yeshivish/chassidish? In the 60's and 70's many of us would go to libraries and read secular books, while attending Bais Yakov's. So – how is that defined? As M.O.? or as yeshivish? I'm all for creating a class unto itself: Jewish naturalists – sorta like the Amish but not quite. Those who enjoy living normally & naturally (including a library book or two, including a DVD or two) with no need to deal with the rat race, stress, high-finance, dog-eat-dog, competition & sound-byte mentality that ALL sectors (i.e. Yeshivish/Chassidish & "modern" – whatever that is..) are caught up in. It would only take a few like minded types amid Modern Orthodoxy, to buy large tracts of land, perhaps in Vineland, and plan pretty layouts, perhaps patterned after Raananah, including tasteful condo developments for the singles & lower-income among us (barring hefty HOA's) to make it happen. But is anyone interested? That's the Q, especially in today's discouraging times when one never knows what will strike next.


  2. Interesting article…I think at the core of it is a far greater problem, one common -and equal to- all religious Jews, MO, haredi, hassidish, litvish, what have you;We all kinda "crossover" between our Judaism and the modern secular lifestyle. We want to be 'good Jews' but also have it good & easy like the gentiles. Hence the Hassid with 18 kids, the Yeshivish Kollel guy and the software engineer from Teaneck must flaunt their 8000SF home, brand new minivan and European designer outfits – PLUS not really wanting to work for it.Kids see through this hypocrisy.And many people sense that all this sectarianism is really good business… but mostly only for the rabbis. IMHO most lay people do not truly, deeply believe their own group's 'core principles' or 'lifestyle' is really true Judaism. They just do what daddy and mommy did, may vocally defend it but inside know its void of content.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: